Amazon Inc. Investing in the Amazon Forest

As part of its commitment to The Climate Pledge — reaching net-zero carbon by 2040 — Amazon has invested in the Agroforestry and Restoration Accelerator, a new nature-based carbon removal initiative. The initiative kicks off in the Brazilian state of Pará, home to 9% of the world’s tropical forest. Pará is facing unprecedented deforestation rates—losing 3,300 acres of forest land every day over the last year. Amazon is working closely with The Nature Conservancy and other local partners to help small-scale farmers restore degraded cattle pastures to native forest and agroforestry. The Accelerator provides farmers with sustainable income through the sales of cocoa and other crops, and will support 3,000 farmers in restoring approximately 20,000 hectares of land—a land mass approximately the size of Seattle—within three years. The goal of the Accelerator is to develop solutions that rapidly scale from initial investment to millions of hectares of degraded pasture with reforestation and agroforestry potential, improving livelihoods in local communities now and for future generations. Join the conversation with Jamey Mulligan, Senior Scientist at Amazon. Reference: The Leaf Coalition.

Recorded May 16, 2022

References:

Right Now Climate Fund

Amazon Announces Investment in Nature-Based Carbon Removal Solutions in Brazil with The Nature Conservancy

Support sustainable bioeconomy commerce – Get to know small-holder bioeconomy entrepreneurs from Para, Brazil

Forest Positive Cocoa in the Amazon

Back to its roots: how is a cocoa revival helping restore the Brazilian Amazon?

Amazon pledges support to forests and communities in the Brazilian Amazon

New initiative aims to boost restoration, agroforestry, and carbon sequestration in the Amazon

Amazon joins global initiative to protect tropical rainforests

WATCH:

  • Jonah Wittkamper
  • Jamey Mulligan
  • Alex
  • Ursula
  • Julia
  • John Bruno
  • Gilberto
  • Marian
  • Rob
  • Jacqueline
  • Tony
  • Danielle Rappaport
  • Unidentified participant

Jonah Wittkamper:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 88th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forcefing economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of Amazon Incorporated, Amazon.com as opposed to Amazon rainforest. Just to be clear, we are going to be looking at a bunch of things. The right now climate fund, the leaf coalition, the agroforestry and restore accelerator. I have got that wrong. Jamie will fix me on it. The climate pledge.

Amazon is one of the world’s largest companies. It’s got its foot in almost every industry around the world and it has a very significant future in the future of Amazon, Amazon Forest, Amazon region sustainability. So to kick off the call, Jamie, tell us a little bit about your life before Amazon.com came along.

Jamey Mulligan:

I want to hear about my life. Okay. How much time do you have? I’ll just quickly introduce myself. Jamie Mulligan. I’m a senior scientist at Amazon. I sort of manage the technical dimensions and strategic dimensions of our work on climate mitigation outside of Amazon’s value chain. I’ve been here for a couple of years. I came from the World Resources Institute where I helped to build their program on carbon removal. Before that, I worked on climate policy and in the in the federal government here in the United States.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Okay. And you have a bit of a presentation to share.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah, I’ll say some things about what we’re doing. We don’t do a lot of PowerPoint in Amazon, so you’ll just have to look at my face as opposed to some pretty slides. So forgive me for that. But I’ve got a short set of remarks about what we’re doing and why we’re doing it and then happy to leave the majority of the time for questions and discussion. I think that’ll probably be most interesting for people.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Sounds great.

Jamey Mulligan:

Great. So first for a kind of high level context in 2019 Amazon co-founded the climate pledge with global optimism and that’s a commitment to net zero by 2040 and under that commitment our first responsibility is to decarbonize our own value chain and we are investing heavily on that front. We have hundreds of people around the company working on that exclusively. Just to give a little more color on that side, it’s so important for as a foundation for everything we then do outside of the value chain. We’re the world’s largest corporate buyer of renewable energy now.

We’ll be 100% renewable powered in a couple of years. We’re investing heavily in electric delivery vehicles. We’ve placed an order for 100,000 delivery vehicles from Rivian. We’re working with other manufacturers as well. We’ve significantly reduced the packaging associated with purchases on Amazon. We’re now investing in materials moonshots to get lowcarbon packaging for what’s left. There are lots of other initiatives as well that too many to mention but at the end of the day we have we’re a sprawling company and we’re a fast growing company. We have an airline, we build buildings with concrete and steel.

We have agricultural supply chains. Of a grocery chain. If there’s a hard to abate source of emissions that you can think of, chances are it’s in our footprint somewhere. And so getting to net zero by 2040 you know 10 years ahead of the Paris agreement, we’re going to have to do more even more than science-based decarbonization inside the value chain. So that’s where that’s where my kind of small but mighty team comes in at Amazon. Where the unit focused on mitigation outside the value chain. And our approach is generally to focus on a small handful of really big plays where we think we can have a big impact and can have the highest confidence in sort of the additionality of our involvement the impact of our involvement.

Our first priority in our strategy is to stop tropical deforestation to do our part in stopping tropical deforestation within a decade. You know five gigatons of emissions every year and if we don’t bring that to an end in that short time frame it kind of doesn’t matter what companies do we’re going to overshoot and we’re all screwed. So that is an urgent priority. Amazon co-created the LEAF coalition with together with Norway in the United Kingdom. We raised more than a billion dollars in seven months. We’re now on track to I think double that in the next handful of months.

And happy to take questions about the leaf coalition later, but I’m today I’m going to talk about our second priority, which is land restoration, especially agroforestry and from a carbon standpoint, nature-based carbon removal associated with land restoration. Now, why are we focusing there? Well, there’s a couple hundred million hectares of formerly forested pasture in the world. Well that means the land is ecologically suitable for tree cover. It’s been deforested. It’s being used as you know to graze livestock today. That land could easily sequest. We’re not going to fully reforest that land.

We need we need to produce food. But as well but you can reintegrate trees into that land in ways that have a significant carbon impact as well as a positive impact for the folks who live there. That land at that scale could easily sequester a gigaton of CO2 annually if you reintegrated trees. Yeah and you can produce food in that way provide and provide shade for livestock. So you can lift and diversify sources of income livelihoods for typically well-income vulnerable people on that land. So the agroforestry and restoration accelerator is Amazon’s mechanism for building and deploying strategies that can scale nature-based carbon removal.

We’re funding it out of the right now climate fund. We have these you know kind of buzzwords for what we’re doing under the climate pledge. Thanks Jonah for giving overview our various mechanisms but that’s kind of how they come together. We launched the accelerator in the state of PAR, Brazil last year with the Nature Conservancy and the World Agroforestry Center and we’re continuing continually building out our strategy and our implementation partners as well. So we’re very much interested in expanding collaboration. PRA is twice the size of France. It’s home to tens of thousands I think maybe even more than 100 thousand I think a couple hundred thousand small holder farmers who would stand to benefit by adopting agroforestry primarily grazing livestock now on formerly forested land has also submitted a proposal to the leaf coalition and agroforestry features prominently in the state’s own strategy and plan to set a course for sustainable economic development.

So here we have an opportunity at the frontier of tropical deforestation. I mean I think 40% of all deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon happens in PRA and the rates have been climbing alarmingly. So here we have an opportunity to capitalize on synergies between our two major initiatives. The leaf coalition which provides resources from the top down for verified reductions in deforestation rates and the accelerator which invests resources directly on the ground in sustainable practices. So if you think about what is actually the endgame on deforestation in places like this, well it definitely entails more effective policy.

So we have to support that. But that policy isn’t going to be durable unless it’s politically sound. And it’s not politically sound unless you’re actually doing the things you need to do to create a vibrant sustainable economic future for the communities in these landscapes. And it seems to us and it seems to the state as well that agroforestry is going to play a key role in that. So what do we do here? Well agroforestry with crops like cocoa and or cacao and acai and palm but a number of others as well.

I’ll come back to that. Can significantly increase incomes per hectare. So this is something this is an intervention where you don’t need to pay people for opportunity costs. You’re actually you’re you need to help them take advantage of unrealized opportunity that they themselves have in front of them. But there are impediments of course where they’d be doing it already. Impediments to adoption are structural. Access to technical assistance, access to inputs, access to credit, access to markets for a whole host of commodities that aren’t being produced at scale and in these often remote areas of the state.

Labor is also a problem and needs to be resolved. So, the accelerator seeks to resolve those impediments for small holders. Let me reframe. The accelerator seeks to help smaller farmers resolve those impediments through a combination of direct support but also increasingly systems level interventions as well. Here’s here’s the farmer journey that we’re starting to create in this program. The farmer enrolls in the accelerator spends 10 days in a neighboring farm that’s been transformed into a working demonstration of not only sustain lucrative you know typically cacao based aggroforestry but also native forest restoration and sustainable pasture intensification as well.

The farmer or as the case may be the farmer’s children get access to an app on their phone where they can ask questions or request a visit from a technician. Get satellite derived agonomic insights when to plant, when to when to prune, when to fertilize, when to harvest. You can order seeds and other inputs and get preferential access to some of those inputs where access today is constrained. Get help applying for a subsidized loan from a national bank or a state bank or filling out the paperwork to secure land title to their land or find offtake contracts that they can choose from with commodity buyers.

The farmer restores largely degraded pasture today to agroforestry and native forest. The agroforestry systems are integrated biodiverse systems. They’re typically primarily arranged around cacao as a staple crop, but it can also be acai or palm. Bananas planted early on to provide early shade until native tree trees native tree species can grow up and provide that shade longer term. Vegetables, black pepper, other crops are planted underneath for immediate income. The carbon sequestered as well a significant amount of carbon on a per hector basis that carbon belongs to the farmer just as the commodities do.

The program conducts all of the monitoring and verification activities for the farm. So that carbon sequestered on the farm actually can be converted into salailable carbon credits, very high integrity credits. And the farmer can choose to trade that carbon for the support that he receives from the program, some or all depending on how much support he decides or she decides to access. We’re also innovating in the carbon quantification methodologies. It’s our view that although there’s been some growth in the carbon market of late that the carbon market is not really going to scale without trust and right now it’s running in my opinion a significant trust deficit.

Both as a result of the lack of demand side integrity. You know, can we really trust that when companies go and buy a carbon credit that they’re doing that in addition to taking responsibility for decarbonizing their own emissions and science b science-based way? Or are they just, you know, buying their way out of the problem? And on the supply side, do we can we trust that the carbon credits that these companies purchase actually represent what they claim to? There are all kinds of holes methodologically in the carbon standards still to date.

They’ve been improving. This space is evolving but we see a number of innovations that can be brought to bear in the quantification of the carbon and we’re doing that in the accelerator. I won’t get we can get more into the details in the Q&A if that’s of interest to people. Not only using technology in the measurement and the monitoring, but also adopting dynamic baselines that allow us to gauge just how well we’re doing. Not relative to where we started, but relative to how the rest of the landscape is doing. And we’re holding ourselves accountable to not just robust quantification of leakage but actually the elimination of carbon leakage from these farms by enhancing agricultural productivity as opposed to displacing it.

Now this isn’t a typical project in this space. In a typical project, a corporate funer would cut a check to an NGO and the NGO would go implement a defined scope of work. It has a start date and an end date. A finite budget. Everything needed to achieve the objectives is paid for, but then that’s where the money ends. The project does good work at some scale and then it sunsets. U that’s not what we’re doing here. We’re not implementing a project. We’re we view this as stimulating a new economy essentially and our funding is structured as a business investment not to create a financial return but to create a carbon return you know it’s money in and it’s and it’s carbon impact out and that’s carbon impact that we can show to our customers and stakeholders under our commitment to the climate pledge.

That structure allows us to think not just about funding good projects but about building a business a financially sustainable engine for scaling these kinds of practices in instead of one-off projects. And we’re employing the same kinds of flywheel strategies that Amazon’s own businesses are built on. We think bringing that mindset, our leadership principles, the lessons learned from our own businesses is a really valuable addition on top of course the money that we can bring to the to these kinds of initiatives. So I’ll close now, but I’ll close just with this to maybe spark interest in the discussion.

I think it’s well more than feasible to bring at least 20,000 small owner farms into this effort in the next three to five years. That would require further scaling from where we started. But that’s I view I would view that as like minimal success for us over the next few years and I think we go a lot bigger just at that scale 20,000 farms given what we assume farmers will do on converting restoring pasture to forest and agroforestry the value of the agroforestry commodity production alone over the first 10 years is more than a billion dollars.

And so that’s just a way to like rightsize your thinking on what’s the opportunity here for investments in farm inputs processing infrastructure wraparound support for farmers and it’s immense is the answer to that question. That we fully expect that Amazon’s investments will stimulate significant additional capital investment by others and we think there will be advantages in coordinating those kinds of investments with the accelerator. We know where these farms are going to be coming online. We can think ahead. We’re doing it in a in a coherent sort of hub-based model to ensure that we can provide that access to market and access to farm inputs.

So we’re not only open to that kind of collaboration, but we’re actually actively seeking it and it just allows us to create even more value for our farmers and for their communities. So I’ll pause there and happy to take any questions.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. So I’m going to come forward with a couple of questions and then I’ll hand it over to the audience. For those who want to indicate their interest in questions, use the hit raise your hand feature or feel free to post in the in the chat. I also want to say that there’s going to be a lot of opportunity for followup here. So people are welcome to post their email addresses and LinkedIns and websites and things like that. First question for me Jamie, one of the stumbling blocks for agroforestry scaling in the region is access to rural qualified labor.

And I wonder if you guys have a solution to that.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah. So, I the idea is not to create some kind of expert workforce that will kind of go around. It’s to train the farmers themselves and their families. And that’s going to be a whole journey. And we I don’t know that we have necessarily the secret sauce for that right now. But the conventional model is typically an NGO you know the extension services are limited in this in this area. So it’s not it’s not non-existent but it’s you can’t expect that if you’re going to scale to this extent the farmers are going to get access to this you know the state agency extension services.

The conventional model is that you send highly trained technicians that are employed by the NOS’s and they do very intensive training and technical assistance with the farmers for like years. And then and then and then they usually the budget ends and then they go home. I that works in a sense. It’s been successful in at th at those farms, those hundreds of farms or whatever the budget allows for. But our thinking is that’s probably not the model that will scale because it’s like the artisal version of it. It’s very intensive.

It’s very costly. So, we’re trying to think about a leaner and more leveraged strategy for disseminating technical knowledge to these farms and their and their families. So that we can scale faster. It we’re going to try a number of different things here, but one element for sure is the are these demonstration farms that I mentioned. So setting up like really the model of how to do this well that other farms can see then bringing far farmers to that demonstration unit and training them on site as a group and in the in the process of doing that training we need to this can’t just be like money beamed in from Seattle and a highly equipped highly trained NGO doing all the work like we’re building a new economy.

It’s not an NGO project. It’s a new economy. So, we have to think about the local institutions and workforce that can take this and continue to run it when we’ve sort of moved on. I don’t mean sunseted the project, but like we have to scale the next community. So, we’re thinking about especially local co cooperatives or it could be, you know, farm associations or some something some organization that’s connected with these farms. And while we’re training farmers, training technicians that’ll be employed by these associations or these cooperatives and can continue to provide that technical assistance need to farms over time.

I mentioned, you know, Amazon is putting money in getting carbon out. Carbon’s probably about 10% of the whole value creation on these farms from these systems. 90% of it is the commodity value. And I mentioned 20,000 farms, a billion dollars worth of commodity value. It’s inevitable that the commodity value chain is going to have to pay for over the longer period of time. The maintenance of these of these practices, the maintenance of technical knowledge, the provision of those kinds of expert services over time, our role is to catalyze, is to stimulate.

And so we want to when we come in, we want to as much as possible build up those local institutions and endow them with the expertise that they need and the workforce, the trained workforce that they need then to take the mantle and to continue on. But that’s I would say that’s where the inventing is happening and I’m not sure that we’ve invented the thing yet. So we’re experimenting in that area in particular.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. One more question to me and then we already have three questions lined up. And it’s about the app that you mentioned. A farmer will be able to turn it on. They’ll be able to find offtakers. They might be able to find financial products that can invest in their extension. Is the app fully developed? How does someone plug in to that? That seems like an exciting opportunity.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah, we have a first version of the app. Was finished a few months ago and so it’s I mean it’s it was built for farmers that are enrolled in the program. So farmers get onto the app when they enroll and when we go come into a community and they show up at the demonstration unit for their training. Part of the training will be here’s the app, here’s how to use it. And we also have an interface for the technicians and an interface for the administrators of the program in respective regions of the state as well.

And this we can collect data through this app that allows us to understand how this is working, what farmers challenges are and their needs are and help us adaptively manage the program over time as well as well as provide value directly to the farmer in a variety of ways.

Jonah Wittkamper:

What’s the app called if I want to search for it and install it on my phone?

Jamey Mulligan:

It’s called Sabia. I don’t know that you’re going to be able to use it without enrolling in the I don’t know. Alex Rudy, my colleague is on the line. Alice, do you want to respond to that?

Alex:

Sure. Yeah, no problem. So, we’re actually still conducting field testing on the app. We have a sort of a prototype version, but it is not yet available for anyone to go search and download. We plan to make it available to the first farmers in our program sometime this summer. And then from there, we would expand to develop out sort of a an ecosystem within the app. Over time to allow u other folks like you’re saying like investment opportunities other products that farmers might need. That buildout will happen over time. We’re right now working on kind of an MVP to get farmers enrolled and to get them reporting data.

And so the timeline for that is the next two or three months for us to finish field testing, but then other features will be added on in months and probably the next year or two to come.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Okay. So we have four questions lining up. The first one is from Ursula, then Julia, John, and Gerberto. Ursula, you’re up.

Ursula:

Hello. My question is about the station. How many cover the farm all the farmers you’re working with?

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah. So, I’ll tell you what we said when we announced it and then and then I’ll give you the real version. So, what we said when we announced it was I think 3,000 farms and 20,000 hectares over the first three years. But I want to underscore my comments about like this isn’t a discrete project with a start and end date and a finite budget. I mean, inevitably when you like pay people to implement stuff, you have to give them a contract that has a start and end date and a budget.

Like the way that we’re approaching this is we’re setting up mechanisms that if they if they’re working and farmers continue to pile in, we’re I fully intend to scale our investment accordingly. So I mean I think upperbound probably could probably get to 50,000 farmers over the next several years if this if this works. And so yeah, I wouldn’t I wouldn’t fixate on a particular number that was in a press release. We’re trying to we’re trying to build a scalable program and we’re actually trying to scale it.

Ursula:

That’s perfect. Thank you.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great, Julia. Thank you. My question would be working in rural value chains we often see that the pressure on local ecosystems and in forests is highest where there are few or nonviable commercial opportunities. So we see deforestation through cattle farming in regions where it’s just difficult to find any agricultural product that could be brought to market. How do you tackle that in the region where you operate? Do you work specifically with smaller farmers that already have a viable commercial operation? Or do you also try to move closer, let’s say, to the forest boundaries into these regions where we really want to avoid the deforestation to progress and try to bring in potential alternatives and form of agroforestry systems to those producers that may be deforesting to use land for cattle farming or other less sustainable options.

Do you have a thought on that? That would be super interesting to hear.

Jamey Mulligan:

A really interesting and kind of insightful question. And there’s a there’s a tension there. I think we’re inevitably we’re going to start where there’s enough material to work with to get started. So, you know, we won’t be parachuting these things into like beyond the frontier and then and then doing the extra hard work to create market access mechanisms there. I think we the sweet spot for us will be probably not the few little areas where they’re actually already doing this because they’re doing this already. They don’t need our help, but just shy of that where you have an established farmer cooperative or association that the institutional mechanisms are there, but the processing infrastructure is grossly inadequate.

Maybe they’re like they’re close enough to get to the road and the road needs to be paved but you could pave that road and then and then you’re there. So we’ll start there I think to try to get to critical mass and really start to scale and then we’ll emanate out is probably the way we’ll do it and then from the frontier backward I think primarily it’s the leaf coalition is the mechanism and then we’ll maybe we’ll meet in the middle but I mean you need rule of law and you need enforcement and that’s where LEAF comes in.

Julia:

Do you support farmers with a commercialization of their product as well or look for industry partners that could be interested in buying from those farmers that work with you?

Jamey Mulligan:

Yes. So we there are variety of ways that we can operate here. One option is we’re having conversations directly with large commodity buyers both from the aggra forestry side as well. We haven’t done this yet. Would like to have start to have conversations on the on the beef side as well because what we’ll have the these farmers will still be cattle ranchers. They just have restored part of their land. They’re also growing cocoa and all these other things, but now they have deforestationfree beef and we’re trying to help them in sustainably intensify their pastures.

You have better managed pasture as well. I think that is ultimately going to be an interesting product for that value chain as well. So we’re in direct conversation with the commodity buyers. What we want to do there is help derisk this for farmers. Get give them confidence that they’re going to be able to access these markets. Give them the choice of entering an advanced offtake agreement if there’s value in that for them. Those things might be attached to things like additional technical assistance or additional inputs or something like that. It’s a common practice already in sort of an informal way.

We can help orchestrate that in ways that give farmers more choice, more flexibility, better value. The other mode of operation is to really invest in co-op itself and let the co-op handle the offtake arrangements but where they need investments in processing infrastructure or they need their technicians trained so that they can continue to provide technical assistance. We’re increasingly thinking about what kinds of how do you create a pact with a local co-op like that where they can envision their future and then we help them get there in a way that makes sense for everybody.

And then we’re also working on other options as well where actually private sector company would work directly with the farmer on the farm and handle basically the expert implementation as well as the offtake. And we’re doing all of these things because we want to create options for farmers, not because we have a particular preference between them, but we want to and we want to experiment with these different modalities and see what works. Thank you.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. John Bruno,.

John Bruno:

Hi. Thank you very much for the a long question answer time. That’s really great. Two questions. One how much listening are you doing with small and steward communities? It you know the visibility and the temptation is often I guess to tell these communities how to do things and I’d like to hear how you’re taking in such a massive amount of data and working with so many partners. How are you making sure that you’re listening? And the second question may seem a little bit self- serving but there’s a lot of positive synergy between ecoourism and agroforestry and opportunities for creation of ancillary revenue.

So have you considered all forms of sustainable development that these communities are looking to engage in? Thank you.

Jamey Mulligan:

Great also great questions. So on the listening side two twofold answer to that. One is we’re establishing an advisory committee that will have you know representatives from all the major stakeholders that you can imagine including at the local level farmers representatives farmers unions that kind of thing. And then we’ll have like local branches in the regions where we’re operating. So we’re getting that kind of on the ground input. But then what I’m perhaps most excited about is I think I think our best shot at scaling is that strategy I mentioned where you’re you’re you’re not just coming in and doing this stuff.

You’re you’re intentionally building up the local institutions who will do this stuff. And if when you operate in that mode you have to you have to listen because you need to get them to own it. And so they’re they’re going to want to create the thing in the way that makes the most sense to them and that meets their interests. And so we’re it’s a little bit we’re just on the cusp of starting to have that kind of roll out strategy and plan, but my expectation is that those thing that strategy that approach will yield not a like, oh, there’s a strategy in Seattle and then and then they did some listening and they tweaked it.

But instead there’s like this co-op has a strategy now and there and it’s been co-developed with the implementers of this program and our role isn’t to decide what it looks like. It’s then to provide the stimulus to help it get off the ground. That’s my vision and hope I guess but obviously these things are very challenging. So we’ll we’ll see how it plays out and we’ll adapt manage that adaptively. I we have not yet gotten ecoourism I would say in our thinking in part because this it’s very hard to get to a lot of these places like the one of our areas of focuses is South Felix to Shingui.

You got to fly to BM and then you got to fly to Maraba and then you got to drive for eight hours. So I don’t know. I want to do some eco tourism myself there but I probably just fly to my house. I don’t know. But if you have insights I would value that. Well, ju just quickly what we always say is lowhanging fruit. Lowhanging fruit. You know, you start it and you give people opportunities and a lot of times these things grow organically. And of course, you know, I’m not arrogant enough to tell anyone at Amazon their business, but that has been a successful strategy in the past for growth of sustainable industries.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Okay. Next up, Gerberto.

Gilberto:

Hi. Jamie, I have a question. It might be a tough question, but you know, there’s been a big political shift in how the Brazilian government thinks of aboriginal people, especially in the context of farming. And so I wanted to know what is sort of your strategy there? I know you’re engaging with lots of stakeholders, but are you engaging in with all voices that sort of get impacted and have already been impacting? You know before it was a farm was it native land right so how is Amazon thinking about that and then the other question totally unrelated but it’s just how do you decide on which commodities you know how much certainty do you have that is the right commodity for the best economic output and making it the best use of that land.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah sorry on your first question you said there’s a lot of discussion around in and then I didn’t quite pick up what you what you noted. What’s the.

Gilberto:

Sorry a lot of sorry a lot of change in the political climate on how the Brazilian government sees Aboriginal lands specifically in various areas of the Amazon, right? And what kind of liberties they’ve taken with those original people that were there. And so how’s Amazon thinking about you know doing regenerative agriculture or transferring those these practices over to the farmers in the context that maybe that land belonged to someone else before and maybe we’ll have new government coming in that may change that strategy.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah sure well I can tell you I mean gen there’s a lot of land conflict in this region. And I can tell you that the conventional mode of operation in the carbon market has been only do work where you have secured fully documented land title. That’s not going to work. It’s just not gonna it’s nice. It’s not that would be great to have. And then you know we’ve heard this before like well maybe the first thing to do is to fix that problem and then and then you can start to scale your stuff and then you know maybe by the time my kids are in college you know we can start to actually start putting trees in the ground.

I just there’s no way we can wait for that. So there’s there a few ways that we think about it and then there’s some safeguards we can put in place. This just a risk for us as an in I mentioned this is investment. So we put money in with carbon credits that get generated as and it’s a swap for the services of the program at the discretion of the farmer. The what we’ll get title those credits and then and then if there’s a an issue around ownership of the carbon then you know we might lose that.

So there’s a risk there. We’re trying to it’s hard to it’s hard to calc I want to say it’s a calculated risk. It’s even it’s hard to quantify the risk but it’s a risk but we know we have to take that risk to deploy the strategy. So, we’re just going to do it and we’ll learn as we go. But we can mitigate the risk in some ways and what’s of course where farmers do have the title. That’s I prefer that. That we can and then once the farmers are in our system and we have information about them, we can we can start to autom automate and streamline the mechanisms with the land titling agency to actually get them the title that they need over time.

And then and then at least and this is our this is like an eligibility requirement basically the land can’t be actively disputed. So you know we’re not going to go up and like invest in a farmer whose neighbor thinks it’s their land. So we have to have mechanisms in place to like flag that for people give them and that land title agency does the same basically when someone applies for land title. So we’ll have that in place. You know, if there’s I think what you’re referring to maybe is and this is happening outside of the recognized indigenous territories for legal reasons basically.

But I think maybe what you’re referring to is this what happens if you know the government decides that this settlement of this established settlement of non-indigenous farmers actually is indigenous land and they recategorize it. That feels like an edge case risk to me, but it’s we’ll just take that. I obviously would never oppose something like that. I you know, if something like that was about to happen, we’d probably steer clear and wait for it to play out. But yeah, that’s just that’s just how we’re how we’re approaching it. Does that answer that question?

That was a hard one. Gilberto, sorry. I welcome it. But yeah, it’s an important one, right?

Gilberto:

But the second one was just on how you decide on which commodity to.

Jamey Mulligan:

Oh yeah. Well, yeah. Right. The short answer is we don’t the farmer does. But so we I think the plan the plan is to like set up provide some options and the options that we would set up or we would do so knowing like there’s you know cocoa processing here. So you could do you could do cocoa here. You know, help the farm understand that stuff. You know, in like Tomasu, there’s a lot of palm plantations. So, actually you can do palm agroforestry there and access markets. That’s not the case in South Felix.

So, so we’ll present them like a menu and these things also have different profiles in terms of like labor intensity, capital intensity, cash flow contours. So, we want to help the farm understand their options and kind of trade-offs on those dimensions. Ideally, we give them like a simple a simple set of things to choose from, but they can make whatever decision they want. Is the short answer.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Next up, we’ll take a question from Marian and Emiliano. If you want, do were you still interested in asking a question? You’re good. Okay. Marian, thanks Jonah and thanks Jamie for.

Marian:

For this great discussion and presentation. God, I had a bunch of questions. So, I guess I’ll just pick one or two. So, I’ll pick two. One question, they’re related. So one question kind of along the lines of what you were just talking about is how you are thinking about potential new deforestation. You mentioned leakage, eliminating leakage very quickly in your remarks, but I was wondering if you could explain a little bit more about that in terms of how you’re working how you’re managing the farmers that you’re working with to make sure that no new deforestation is part of their commitment or is that and a second question is in terms of local institutions and support.

I’m wondering if you could talk a little bit about any interactions you’ve had with the government of PA, the state government, and if you’re, you know, how you’re interacting with local governments, and whether or not the Amazon Governor’s Coalition and their regeneration plan figure at all into the work that you’re doing. And then I had one more question. It might be too many, but that’s just about figuring out ways to get these farmers access to other capital in the future going forward if that’s something that you’ve thought about.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah. Okay. You don’t have to answer them all if it’s too many.

Jamey Mulligan:

No, I can’t answer them. I’m trying to Okay. So, the first one is right leakage. Was it the first one’s leakage? What was the first one? Yeah, leakage. Okay. All right. So, yeah, I mean there’s a pact from the farmer. Yeah. Yeah. The farmer said you’re getting this assistance and the expectation is that is that you’re going to invest in the land that you have and restoring the land that you have. You’re not going to continue to deforest and we and we have you know we have the polygons and we’re watching the polygons so we can detect that deforestation when it happens that approach is fairly I don’t know I think that’s common in these kinds of projects.

What we’re the step further that we’re doing is on market based leakage. So if you just if you just reforest some pasture, no matter how degraded it, it was had some level of productivity. You know that we it’s very difficult to quantify then okay what happens to beef prices if you do that at scale and then and then how does the value chain respond and does that further intensify deforestation through market-based mechanisms? And the real answer to that is we have no idea. We have no idea the carbon leakage rate associated with the displacement of that of that production.

It’s just it’s just too complicated basically to do it precisely and the carbon standards are like 20%. And you just take your deduction and you’re on your way. But the truth is we have no idea. So our approach is let’s m at least maintain that production in the like either on site or within like the broader you know kind of surrounding landscape so that we can have we can then have confidence in our leakage quantification because it’s zero and we know it’s zero. So you maintain productivity and you don’t have that market based effect but you still need to make sure that the farmers themselves are keeping their land keeping the forest they have left intact.

Second question was local government, right? Or was that the third?

Marian:

Yeah, particularly the government of PA and the Amazon Governor’s Coalition and their plans going forward.

Jamey Mulligan:

The we’ve had a lot of engagement with the state. They’re great set of folks and that this kind of thing features prominently in their own plans. So you know obviously around the leaf coalition but also around the accelerator I think the state’s thinking on restoration is to sort of platformatize how they operate like they went out and they created their own project kind of like this fairly limited and then they realized you know what actually what we should be doing is seeking to support all projects like this across the state through policy in this platform the sustainable territories platform.

And they’ve asked us to plug into that not only as kind of a project so to speak but also and I mentioned this earlier but like the way that we’re operating is not like just a defined discrete project it’s actually like stimulus that stimulants that can that can be le leveraging other projects as well. So we’re going to we’re going to kind of plug into that state platform as not only as a doer but like an enabler if that makes sense across the state. So this I think there’s there are relationships now and connections and coordination happening and then to the extent that they’re successful and relief there’s going to be an infusion of funds that will be reinvested in a number of ways and this and this kind of thing will be one of them.

So I you know there’s sort of this flywheel virtuous cycle that’s poised to happen. And now I’ve forgotten your third question.

Marian:

The third question was about greater access to capital beyond your project as these.

Jamey Mulligan:

Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, we don’t want to be the only capital provider. And the and the short of it is every time we spend money to do something for a farmer, we ask for a commensurate amount of carbon in return. And so to the extent that we can bring in like subsidized you know concessionary loans from a government bank or whatever then we can we can help the farmer collectively the same amount with less of our money and that means the farmer gets to keep more of the carbon the farmer can sell the carbon and so you know we’re try the farmer is sort of our customer here right in a not in a crude sense but in Amazon is everyone knows is the world’s most or customer-centric company and in this instance we’re viewing the farmer as our customer.

We want the farmer to succeed. We want to create as much value for that farmer as possible. So in short, we’re you know we’re having discussions with state banks, national banks. We’re talking to the commodity buyers themselves about providing some inputs as well that would help the farmer reduce the comfort of farmer’s capital need. And then to the extent that any of you all want to participate in that, we are open for that dialogue.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay, let’s move on. We’ve got about 10 minutes left and three people with questions. So, let’s keep them brief. Rob.

Rob:

Yeah. Hey, Rob with aspiration. I think my questions generally been covered in previous responses. But maybe just to get specific clarity on this we’re making investments into natural restoration ourselves and trying to make this a scalable and investable kind of business investment rather than philanthropy. So sounds like we’re working on similar things with a similar model. But maybe just could you clarify? I think I heard that you Amazon would off take the carbon credits at the farmer’s discretion and then maybe as the second piece of that do you view this as eventually becoming integrated into the leaf coalition or as you scale it would you view this as kind of a complimentary initiative to LEAF yeah maybe just talk to that.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah we’re a service provider we provide services to the farmer in exchange services cost money. So you know it’s a it’s an exch it’s a transaction with the farmer. We provide services the farmer provides carbon and we structure those things in ways to make sure make sure absolutely sure that those that those exchanges are fair and if something wonky happens with prices they get they get revisited automatically. But that’s the short answer there. And then this will always be separate from LEAF is simple. It’s big. It’s very simple. You jurisdiction reduce deforestation rates, you get paid and then you got to reinvest that money in further progress.

That’s what LEAF will do. But we see a ton of value in colllocating investments like we have in the accelerator with jurisdictions that are strengthening policy under the LEAF coalition because it builds that sustainable economic future that makes those LEAF policies not leaf policies but the policies you know association with leaf more politically durable and helps these communities to thrive even as you’re reducing deforestation. Okay. Jacqueline,.

Jacqueline:

Hi Jamie. How’s it going? Jacqueline here from Capital for Climate. My question really is about long-term offtakes. I know you talked a lot about like offtakes of carbon from the farmer, but in terms of like the produce itself the aggroforestry produce itself, you know, does Amazon actually have any strategy with regards to that or is this up to the farmer to you know, locate buyers for that for their produce?

Jamey Mulligan:

We’re helping them find buyers and or we’re strengthening local co intend to strengthen local co-ops who can do that work on behalf of farmers. So as I mentioned we’re having conversations with the commodity you know value chain actors and orchestrating basically allowing them to provide offtake agreements to the farmers directly. I don’t know about long term but like once you strengthen market access you know it should be there over the long term. Yeah.

Jacqueline:

Okay, perfect.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Tony, you’re on mute. You’re still on mute. Tony, can you go Jamie?

Tony:

Hey, this is Tony Lyn. Quick question. Have you taken a look at some of the other digital platforms that are emerging in places like India and Africa that are providing multiple services to small holders on in a digital environment? Inputs, credit, market access.

Jamey Mulligan:

Oh, we’ve I mean we’ve seen a couple of apps in this a few apps in this kind of space. It’s not rocket science like we just pulled one together. Now we now we have one of our own. So, and one that we can modify over time. I don’t know that we’ve done like a comprehensive, I don’t know, crosswalking or kind of evaluation of pros and cons or advantages or whatever. We just, this was just something that we could create fairly easily and so we did it.

Tony:

Thank you. Danielle.

Danielle Rappaport:

Hey there. Thanks so much for the presentation. I’m alidia mono in transit. My question kind of relates to Jacqueline’s question about you know that your plans for facilitating these offtaking relationships and how you’re ensuring that the that the value creation actually stays in the region and whether Amazon.com intends on investing in regional capacity to aggregate value in the form of locally manufactured products rather than just exporting all of the value out of the region in the form of raw commodities.

Jamey Mulligan:

Yeah, great question. I mean, fir honestly our first priority is to make sure that the farmer is able to sell their commodity at market price. That has we have to make sure that happens. Then from there over time you can you know work to strengthen local processing infrastructure and bu and build up that value added element locally and the fact that we’re I mean fully intend to do that we do that by you know our sort of local institution strategies I mentioned are building up those local co-ops they’re going to want to own a lot of that value ad themselves and so yeah the answer is yes it’s not necessarily the case that Amazon itself will be the investor in those things Maybe we will.

It depends case by case. But as I mentioned, we’re building a new economy. So, you know, investment can come from anywhere for those things. We’ll probably help to orchestrate it in some ways. In some ways, we could probably derisk. In some ways, we can just provide data and information that an investor would need to understand like is the throughput going to be there for this? You know, we can we can help with those kinds of things. But my expectation is that yeah, that’ll that’ll be the trend is toward that local processing, but we’ll see how it goes.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Other questions? We still got a couple minutes left. I have one which is about the other members of the LEAF coalition. Are any of them involved in the accelerator?

Jamey Mulligan:

At the moment the accelerator is I would say in its it’s still growing up and so it’s for to keep it lean. Amazon’s the only funer at the moment. That might change over time. We’re not trying to poach Leaf companies yet, but you know we welcome investment alongside what we’re doing here in this landscape by anybody. I guess that’s the that’s the short answer is no fair for a leaf.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay. It’s certainly the case that when Amazon puts its toe in the water in an industry, it mobilizes lots of other opportunities, lots of other companies to join the party, so to speak. So I definitely expect there to be lots of economic development followon. You guys want to be a catalyst. I predict that you will be. We are now at the top of the hour. This is where we switch over to water cooler time where we have unstructured conversation. Jamie, are you available for five 10 more minutes to stick around with us?

Jamey Mulligan:

Unfortunately, I’ve got a hard stop. Okay. Okay. Well, the chat room will stay open. I’ll be here. Thank you so much for joining us. Any last comments or questions from anybody?

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay, it’s unstructured time. Thanks so much for joining us. It was really great to have you. Everyone’s encouraged to leave their information in the chat to facilitate networking etc. The room will stay open for a little while.