Amazon Forest Crime Prevention and Indigenous Protectors
The Forest Forces Foundation works to protect nature by forming alliances that connect traditional forest communities with access to technology, science, law enforcement, and justice, at local, national, and international levels. With an estimated 90% of deforestation deemed to be illegal, indigenous communities can achieve new levels of situational crime prevention through collaboration with public prosecutors, the use of GPS-equipped digital camera surveillance, and the implementation of best practices from criminology and crime science. What support do indigenous communities need? How are public prosecutors involved? How, why, and when is crime prevention more effective than law enforcement? Who are the partners and law enforcement agencies that can help mitigate the illegal activities promoted by cattle, soy, mining, and logging interests? Can these strategies be integrated with new approaches to landgrabbing prevention? Join us to meet criminologist Tim Boekhout van Solinge and learn.
Recorded January 24, 2022
References:
Pastoral Land Commission / Comissão Pastoral da Terra
GPS-Supported, Community-Based Forest Crime Prevention in the Brazilian Amazon
Organized Forest Crime: A Criminological Analysis with Suggestions from Timber Forensics
Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon
10 Essential Facts about Land Reform in Brazil
Insecure Land Rights in Brazil: Consequences for Rural Areas and Challenges for Improvement
Panorama of Property Rights in Rural Brazil: Legislation, Regularization and the Forest Code
Evolution of Land Rights in Rural Brazil: Frameworks for Understanding, Pathways for Improvement
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah
- Tim Boekhout van Solinge
- Amy
- Ursula
- Antonio
- Julia
- Christina
- Chip
- Tom
- Ruth
- Christian
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 70s something call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of Tim Boekhout van Solinge and I’m going to put that person on mute. Hold on one second. I’d like everyone to be on mute unless you’re speaking. So Tim, tell us a little bit about yourself. Where, where did you grow up? Tell us about what you did before the Amazon came into your life and how the Amazon came into your life.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Well, I’m so my name is Tim. My last name is really difficult to pronounce, but in Dutch we say, but I’m used to many different types of pronunciations of my name. So I’m born in the Netherlands. But I’ve lived in many countries. I consider myself a global citizen. So but I grew up in near Amsterdam where I currently live. I grew up in a suburb. So from a Dutch father, my father was in the military where he was a colonel in the military Dutch army. My mother is Indonesian. Dutch which used to be a colony.
So she was born in the colonies as we speak. So I’m of mixed nature. My mom my mom was born in the tropics. My dad is in the Netherlands. So I was interested in the Amazon as from a kid when I was 10 or 12 years old. And I heard in school that where the Amazon the river goes into the ocean there’s so much water flowing into the ocean that 100 to 150 kilometers into the ocean the water is still fresh water. And when I heard this as a kid, this got me.
This fascinated me and I always since that age, I wanted to see the Amazon River. And so in 2003, I went there for the first time. And then I fell in love with the Amazon. And well, then things started and later on I lived there. But that’s how that’s how I got involved into the Amazon.
Jonah:
Nice. Tell us a little bit about your academic career.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
So I graduated my masters was in 94. I studied geography and geography of developing countries. I always wanted to make a contribution to the better world. Think about poverty and the environment. So I studied geography in Amsterdam and also in Paris to and I also studied a bit in Jamaica for my master thesis and in the Palestinian university as part of an exchange program. I always wanted to see as much of the world as possible and I also kind of had was interested in crime and conflicts. I don’t know don’t really know why but I had this interest in so and then I have a PhD in criminology.
I happened to I became a drug expert when I was studying in Paris at the Sabon. I was reading about the global drugs economy, the illegal economy of course and it’s kind of fascinating and I had studied in Jamaica and where marijuana is the biggest export product and you have criminal organizations and cocaine. So I had seen a little bit of this crime and I became a drug expert. I’ve written several books PhD including 2004 but after 2004 I really shifted to environmental crime and mainly illegal deforestation and illegal logging.
I had become a lecturer in criminology. I was quite successful actually as a as a drug expert. I was invited in the by the in the Senate of Canada and for example in the European Parliament, Dutch Parliament, but I knew that wasn’t my passion. I wanted to contribute to a better, let’s say, greener, more sustainable, more environmentally friendly world.
Jonah:
Nice.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
And so I focused on the Amazon. I decided, okay, I want I went to the Amazon for in 2003 for the first time when I was speaking at a criminology conference in Rio de Janeiro, the global criminology conference. And then I went to the Amazon to see the Amazon River. And I knew I wanted to do research there. I already knew that. So, but first have to learn language and get to know the country and you know etc.
Jonah:
We’ll get into that. We’ll we’ll talk about the birth story of the forest forces down Foundation. Let’s just get in a couple definitions to help people. What is what is the study of criminology and crime science?
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Criminology and crime science are both academic studies of crime and criminology is basically more about the criminals. Some people say it’s understanding the criminals and it’s true a lot of if you think if you look at really the study program it’s a lot about why do they do it and in crime science is more about understanding crime and crime science is more than criminology really focused on crime control and trying to reduce crime and thinking in the interest of victims and helping victims and to reduce crime. So it’s more practically oriented towards reducing crime whereas criminology is more the academic science of understanding crime and some people say almost you know condoning or explaining and trying understand the law breakers or criminals but that’s the main difference.
And then there’s criminal justice studies especially for people in the US because criminal justice studies is well the how the criminal justice system works in Europe that’s part of criminology but in North America that’s kind of separated. So this I also use insights and theories and best practices of criminal justice studies but we’ll get to that I think. And what is situational crime prevention? Well, crime see that’s really crime prevention but all kinds of types of crime prevention. Situational means nothing more than adapt to every situation. For example, if you have a if you have organized crime, you need another type of intervention and you have teenagers shoplifting in the supermarket.
But you know you can initiate install all types of crimerevention strategies. And what’s interesting about crime prevention is that usually by non-law enforcement actors. So it’s you citizens neighborhood watch what many people know is an example of crime prevention that citizens in a neighborhood have an app or have a phone number and then they can report crime they can organize or that shop owners by a security and you know it’s they pay the security it’s not official law enforcement and or they have an app if there’s false money going around I got some false counterfeit money they put it in the app and then you know there’s all kinds of intervention that you can do citizens with law enforcement in order to reduce the opportunities to commit crime.
That’s making it harder to commit crime. That’s it. And because of the idea of rational choice theory, one of main theories of in social sciences, people make this okay benefit risk analysis. Okay, burglar can I what’s the risk? What’s the benefit? So people always make this kind of costbenefit analysis and then by making it harder you can influence human behavior that’s okay well forget it you know they won’t do it because a lot of crimes are just what opportunity crimes they people use the opportunity.
Jonah:
Great okay so using this understanding what is the forest forces foundation.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
So when I lived in the Amazon for I was leading a big scientific project 1 million Colombia in Brazil and Utach University where I worked at the time about conflicts and cooperation over natural resources because there’s all types of conflicts over natural resources about deforestation, illegal deforestation. So what can you do? And living there for four years time, six months per year I was living there. I thought I’m a criminologist to begin with. I’m supposed to have some kind of smart answer because what the problem one of the problems now is that a lot of biologist and trying to develop anti-rime policies in the Amazon and with wildlife trade also I think no but we can learn from crime from criminology and crime science.
So I thought and I thought we have we want to preserve the Amazon and 80 to 90% of the deforestation is illegal so we have to use insights and best practices of criminology and crime science. So I started to reflect on that and then I thought we have to work with the communities and I tried I started thinking around 2012 11 13 would it be possible to develop some kind of neighborhood watch for the Amazon that’s how I started him so I first did a pilot a scientific pilot funded by university foundation which enabled me to buy GPS cameras waterproof cameras and I did a pilot to test if this could work you analysis.
So with GPS cameras and indigenous communities and it worked and so you have to test three things. One, so I with crowdfunding I gave GPS cameras, waterproof GPS cameras to communities on the deforestation front line and I wanted to test three things. One, will they take pictures of illegal forest activities because it can be very dangerous or there can be division within the community to not want it for some kind of reason. First, will they take pictures of illegal forces? Two, will they take pictures, so GPS reference pictures to the law enforcement authorities, which are usually in towns or in cities, can be one, two, three, four days travel to bring the pictures because there’s not generally not internet or something.
So, and then three, if the law enforcement authorities get the pictures of illegal force activities, will those law enforcement authorities take action? And so we tested this at several locations and it was one two and three was yes. So the even so there was no one paid. I only gave these cameras to the indigenous leaders. I said look this is a camera for you. I want nothing in return only sometimes a few copies of your pictures. But if this camera has to protect your forest and because it has a GPS function, this GPS is very important because the law enforcement authorities, they need the GPS of they because they need the location of the crime because the Amazon doesn’t have street addresses.
So for the authorities, but the authorities need to register the crime and in also to pro and in court they need the location and that’s the GPS. So I told him this. I said, look, the authorities need the GPS location. You can provide that. And well then it’s interesting to see will they take a pictures will they bring it to town it’s and yes they do because they have an intrinsic interest in doing that because they are forest dependent communities they know they need the forest they live from the forest so it’s in interest so they will actively bring those pictures and from the law enforcement authorities and this is criminal justice studies you have to know which institutions are the strong institutions you know and non-corrupt that will take action that want to protect forest.
And those are the public prosecutors and there the federal police and also the environmental protection agency. And so they all got these pictures and well some of them have sometimes corruption problems but others don’t. For example, the federal police and prosecutors you know it’s very rare to hear corruption cases in those institutions. So they are really trustworthy institutions. So and it’s interesting of course law enforcement is very under underst staffed at this moment and they don’t have budgets because there have been severe budget cuts over the last few years but interestingly if evidence of illegal force activities is presented to them on you know and then it’s much easier for them to take action that because that’s how I thinking about criminal justice studies how can you make it easy to them to the forest law enforcement system how can you connect communities, forest communities, indigenous form and non-indigenous that don’t want the deforestation, which is illegal.
And some of the trustworthy institutions, they’re on the same line. They don’t want illegal deforestation. So, how can you connect them? And that’s the GPS. The GPS is the connection because the authorities, law enforcement needs GPS, but they are in the cities. They’re far from the crimes. But the force communities, they’re near the crimes and they can provide they can collect the GPF GPS evidence that the authorities need. And so there was a pilot and what happened with chief dada he’s my main he’s an indigenous chief my main partner and I gave the first camera to him in 2015 and in 2016 that we had our biggest first success because he with the with the GPS because you have to understand indigenous territories they are protected according to federal law outside are not allowed to in to go inside but there’s no gate So they before that they were already patrolling their territory but they would meet loggers and they said hey this is our territory.
No we have a concession here we are allowed to log here. Discussions complicated violence threats maybe but now they have the GPS camera. They switch it on. I said look these are the coordinates. You are inside indigenous territory. We’re not allowed here. We’re going to take pictures of you. And well that’s how it how it started. And they took pictures of buildings of logging companies inside indigenous territories. There were piles of logs inside indigenous territories. So they had taken pictures with the GPS camera. And then they went to town. The chief went to town and he said, “I have pictures of illegal force activities.” He gave the GPS coordinates.
They type it in on their in their system. They get the satellite picture immediately and said, “Oh yeah, it looks like the same buildings. Looks like the same piles of logs. And then they prepared a law enforcement operation and five days five days later was a joint operation federal police environment protection agency Obama with the chief on board. They have the GPS coordinates so they can go there straight away. They were hanging above indigenous territory. Yes, these are the buildings. It is in indigenous territory with the GPS. So it’s the chief says not with his permission.
So it’s illegal. It is that simple. If you’re not with if the chief didn’t give permission it’s illegal and you’re not and so that’s the it’s very easy to prove and interestingly these logging companies they had permits from the state of par this is par state the leading deforestation state in Brazil for over 10 years but indigenous territories is federal higher legislation so there were these permits were illegal according to federal legislation so because he had is GPS proof all the forest management plans of all the lunging companies were cancelled by the federal authorities and all the logging companies are out.
So this was a very yeah simple basically way to prove the illegality of the illegal presence of the logging companies inside federal indigenous territory. So that’s how it started in 200 and this was for me the proof it yeah the thing that I had thought in my head at in my office at university that it could work that it is it can work to connect the forest guardians with the law enforcement system and then you get the circle the round circle because then law enforcement authorities have acted and then the perpetrators because this is the how the theory works Now the potential perpetrators know I these indigenous are with cameras that take pictures of us and these pictures will go to the authorities and the authorities will take action and then you have the model then you have deterrence and then the potential perpetrators know I deter works they know we might be photographed the authorities take action and they stay away and this indigenous territory no longer has illegal logging activities.
They’re all gone and it’s one of the very few indigenous territories without illegal logging activities. So, it kind of works the deterrents and they’re continued patrolling because I haven’t mentioned that they control their patrol, excuse me, their territory constantly, men and women now over 50. They’re patrolling with GPS equipment and other equipment, but to patrol to protect their territory against illegal invasions. I love it. A triple alliance between direct relationships with public prosecutors, new technology through GPS cameras, and partnership with local traditional populations, in this case, indigenous people. It seems like a formula that can scale this land conflicts thing.
Let’s get into that there’s an unknown there. Can you tell us about the pastoral land commission and their famous reports? Yes. So the pestal land commission CPT in is an NGO it’s in Brazil Brazilian NGO which you can find all over the Amazon and they were created in I think in the mid 80s by the Catholic Church during the military dictatorship and CPT is so kind of human rights branch you can say of the Catholic Church although they’re not all Cathol It’s really kind of an independent semi-independent NGO, but they have a huge network all over the Amazon with little offices always behind the Catholic Church and the Catholic Church give them some protection also.
Of course, it’s the biggest Catholic country in the world. So they have all these correspondents and they visit all the time the community. So they know very well all the conflicts, the issues and the deforestation issues. So is if it’s mining, if it’s logging, if it’s cattle, if it’s soy, and they publish a report based on the knowledge and network of all these correspondents and it’s already 35 years a re annual report, land conflicts in the Amazon. And it’s really kind of the bible if you not bible but encyclopedia or the or the best report really about all the issues all the land conflict issues in the Amazon and it’s quite detailed.
You can see, oh, this community has a problem with a logging company or this one with a mining or and you to understand the problems because sometimes when you see certain films on TV or even some certain promotion of certain NOS’s, you see only animals and trees in nature. But one of the things that strikes me when I go to the Amazon that’s okay the there’s all people all over living of course the density is low the small communities but still they’re all over and that strikes me and I think if we want to protect the Amazon that’s what I learned we have to work with the communities they are already there we all we all want to protect the Amazon but we are not there and we should work with the people who are there who are even more motivated than we are because they are directly dependent on the forest.
So it’s they’re fighting for their survival. So we have to use work we have to work with them or imagine you live in a forest any one of you and the world wants to protect the forest. You would also appreciate it that the international community will talk to you because you live there you know best what’s going on and you probably also have ideas about how to protect it. And I think this local intelligence is so valuable because you know of course they know because even the loggers or they hear things you know because a lot of people emphasize oh we should use satellite technology.
Of course I’m totally in favor of using technology but I’m also in favor of using the local intelligence. And I noticed that a lot of people assume that it’s kind of difficult to work with the indigenous. But interestingly, I find it very easy to work with the indigenous. Of course, you have to win their trust, but I’ve won the trust after working there for many years. But what I like about the indigenous, they have a very strong oral culture. So, they talk very clearly in Portuguese and most of them spoke to Portuguese.
I speak Portuguese as well. They talk very clearly, but then when I talk, they listen very carefully. They don’t have to make notes because they remember they remember very clearly and so the communication is very clear.
Jonah:
Let’s let’s go ahead and move into the next question. Tim, are you still there? Your camera has frozen. While we’re Oh, Tim, you’re back. Can you hear me?
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes, I can hear you.
Jonah:
Okay, let’s go ahead and move into the next question. Just one or two more questions for me and then we’ll open it up. There are already people who have questions for you. So you told me about a partnership between a university Impa and the Ford Foundation and the process of digitizing the land registries of 10 different municipalities. Who were the partners involved and what were the results? What were their discoveries?
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
So this was indeed well the partnership is the state prosecutor office of the state of par and the federal university of par in blem and I’m let’s say their informal partner and but they and they with the help of Ford foundation they scanned land documents of the notary offices in 10 municipalities because the problem of par and this is Let’s say the background problem of the deforestation in the Amazon and especially in PA state the leading deforestation state for over 10 years is that there is no digital digitalized digital land registry system.
So what happens in reality is that there is three times more land registered than there is land in reality. So that’s on average three times. So certain pieces of forest are registered 10 times in 10 different notary offices. So this is how land grabbing works. A lot of land is illegally registered. So there is even some people buying who think they buy land, they don’t buy land, they just buy some kind of paperwork.
Jonah:
Sorry Tim, I accidentally muted you. If you could if you could just go ahead. Yes, go ahead.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
So what they did with they got a few million from the Ford Foundation and in order to really to go to all the notary offices and scan all those documents and then you under and what they then discover that there’s a lot of overlapping and overlapping between farmers but also overlapping in indigenous territories in national parks. So there’s a lot of private lands illegally registered in well all over the place. Can be indigenous territories, can be national parks, can be federal rivers, federal land, state land. So a lot of land is illegally registered and now there is another way to check it there.
So if you scan it and digitalize it and put more maps, then you can see well all these double over overlappings but you can also trace it also enables to trace the history of land documents and then you can see which land documents are genuine and which ones are fake and so most of them are fake and well I know and there’s still a lot of municipalities that they haven’t done yet. So I mean on the long term can we can only really stop the lands grabbing and deforestation issue if there is a digitalized lands registry.
Jonah:
Okay two more questions for me and then we’re going to open it up to the audience. One, tell us about the kadaso ambient huro car as it’s called. And then finally, I’d love for you to reflect on the pros and cons of incarceration and avoiding incarcer incarceration as a strategy to deal with these issues.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
So, the car is a it’s a kadustra system. So farmers can register land that they if they say I own land or use land they can register that in a in a cadusta system which is aimed to get some control over land use. So the idea in itself is good to have the registry system. The problem however is that the car system you Brazilians can register any land almost they can also register land a car inside indigenous territory or inside a national park the system doesn’t filter those areas out so for example there are around 10,000 private properties car registrations of private properties inside indigenous territory 10,000 it’s a communication of the federal prosecutor’s office.
So those are all illegal. So it’s a lot of these well we cannot say we cannot quantify how many are but let’s say a substantial part of them are illegal and one example is illegally registered in indigenous territories others in national parks. So sometimes so this gives people who don’t know this gives the appearance of legality. People think and people sell these documents, registrations as if as if they sell them as a kind of proof that they own the land, but it’s not. They have only registered the land. It’s a land claim actually and not land real land tenure or not real a land title.
It’s a land claim and many of them are illegal and they’re supposed to be approved at one point by the authorities, but this they’re so behind this that they haven’t done this yet. So, and one of the problems is that international investors or banks or supermarkets that buy products from the Amazon, for example, beef or soy or timber, they don’t know this and they and a lot they don’t know that car registrations can be illegal and they don’t ask difficult questions. So, that’s how we so this doesn’t solve the problem.
This car registration, it can be legal but it can be totally illegal as well. And then about incarceration, well, we know, you know, the Amazon and especially par state is called the wild west of the of Brazil and the Amazon. It’s an area with a lot of lawlessness and I think so there’s crime. What you can do with all these crime? Okay, on one hand we need more law enforcement for sure, but the other but if you want to protect nature, I think the emphasis should be on crime prevention because law enforcement then people will go to prison and I wish no one to go to prison in Brazil.
It’s horrible Brazilian prison. So my strategy is not to punish people and to put people behind bars, but really to protect nature and to apply criminology and crime science to make it harder. So really to put the emphasis on crime prevention, force crime prevention rather than force law enforcement. And I think force crime prevention and in general from the literature, criminology and crime science, we know crime prevention is always more cost effective than law enforcement, you know, because law enforcement is very expensive. Police and all these court cases and in the case of nature forest the wildlife it’s even more important to apply crime prevention because we want to preserve it and not react afterwards we have want to prevent the illegal destruction so I think that’s has become my mantra a little bit we have to apply much more force and wildlife crime prevention.
Jonah:
Great thank you for that Tim I have feeling the audience is going to be very excited by your offerings I’m going to make one announcement and then I’m going to open the door to questions. And we already have four people asking questions lined up. The announcement is if this is your first call and you’re not yet on the mailing list of the Amazon Investor Coalition, please message me your email address and name. And there’s an invitation to everybody to feel free to post your email addresses, your LinkedIns, your organization. These calls are also very good for networking.
It’s not just about presenters and asking presenters questions. So first up and Amy, that’s you. I’m going to just frame a little bit your question. So Tim and I after I learned about the story about the federal university of PA and this digitization of these 10 different municipalities, talked about the idea of, building a solution like that for the entire Amazon. And that could be a private company, right, that has its business solving land conflicts. And there could be venture capitalists around the world that invest in that. Or maybe it could be, scaling the work of the Cadasta Foundation and building in an income generation angle.
So, I know you’re going to have a great question, but in addition to asking your great question, it’d be great if you could introduce yourself. So, Amy Cookar,.
Amy:
Hi Tim. Thanks so much. I have learned a ton from you and also Jonah, the resources you put just in this in this event list were amazing. I’ve got a lot of reading to do. So, thank you for that. Super interesting. So, Cadasta Foundation, Cadasta Foundation is a nonprofit global organization and our focus is on advancing land and resource rights globally for vulnerable communities. We work with we work in cities, farms, and forests around the world in 42 countries. We have over five and a half million people mapped, people’s rights mapped on our platform and in about 3,000 communities working with over a 100 partners on the ground.
So, we don’t do the mapping, we don’t do the data collection, we enable local partners to do that. And we really believe and Tim what you were talking about you know getting technology in the hands of local people that is exactly what we’re doing at Cadasta. We have local partners on the ground and everything from small community- based organizations to national civil society organizations or local NOS’s or international ones. So we kind of have run the gamut. And when you were when I was listening to you talk about the GPS and the cameras and empowering those communities to report that and then collaborate with law enforcement.
You know, one of my one of my questions in my head was what about a couple of things. One what about communities where that land is not recognized as indigenous land? In other words, it’s in the middle of somebody’s car registration that is illegal. And there is no for you know documentation that’s recognized so that type of activi activity would be seen as illegal. So that and what and then the second sort of thing that came into my mind is what if we upped the ante and not only had GPS cameras but also actually enabled communities to map and document their own community boundaries particularly those communities that are not yet recognized by the government.
So that the relationship between the people and the land was very clear in those circumstances. And this isn’t just for Brazil. This is for the whole Amazon to establish that people land relationship and push forward a legal process within that jurisdiction so that you have those GPS coordinates for the entire piece of territory of that indigenous group or community in addition to the GPS information. In other words, you’ve got satellite data. You can link it to things like global forest watch you know threat alerts but you’re really you’re you’re able communities are able to do it on a much larger scale because you’re not only using a GPS camera you’re also using that data set on the relationship between people in the land and you’re trying to formalize that.
So that those are the two things that came to mind when as you were talking. So I’ll just stop there.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes. Well, thank you Amy. Great question. You obviously know more about the subject with the importance of mapping boundaries. I guess no yes absolutely and I’ve actually I am we are helping communities with mapping their lands and boundaries. Actually another indigenous community I we are supporting and with Tom Wheeler because Tom Wheeler has a foundation the Singi foundation he basically supports indigenous organizations and so that they can organize and I was already working on the ground and so we are combining our work but so we are supporting these indigen communities with mapping boundaries but now the challenge because this is par state and par state is a very violent state has a higher homicide rate than the city of Rio Janeire.
So this is a rural state, forested state, almost twice the size of Texas for the for the people from the US. So very big state with again a higher homicide rate than the city of Rio. So it’s very dangerous. Now when I agree with everything it’s good, but there are major challenges. One is violence because what happened? So this is a real case. It’s another indigenous community I’m supporting. Soy farmers have registered land there with car. These indigenous were living in the forest. They never they’re just living in a forest.
They never thought, oh, let’s register in town, you know, let’s let register. They never they were just living there. But suddenly the soy farmers have land registered. And as if this is, we know one of the most common conflicts in the Amazon. They said, hey, where were you living here? Yeah, but you haven’t registered. You mean so they don’t exist really for the authorities. But then I help them to register and they are indigenous and they now have also a land claim. So with the G but because the GPS cameras you can walk your borders and you can map it with GPS.
That’s what they did. And then actually I also paid for an official GPS guy and he did it again. So and then they made their map. This is we this is our traditional land and they went to the authorities but then there was the reaction from the soy farmers because the soy farmers were first the only ones who had registered it and they export their soy and all but now the indigenous also have a registration. Now the law works like this. Now the soy farmers can never get their different land height because the people who are already living there, the indigenous have a land claim as well.
And so if there will be a definite land claim, it will be the indigenous and not the soy farmers who arrived 10 years ago. And but because the soy farmers are now pissed off because the indigenous registers and then started the violence and the threats because they are angry now that they won’t that they cannot get land rights to soy far. So it can create problems and violence as well. So you really have to so yes it can work but you have to be careful and because it can increase violence.
So that’s why the access to justice is so important which Tom Wheeler and I we’re emphasizing you need this line to the justice and trustworthy inclusive institutions that they can help you know and protect these communities against because there was the international human rights commission of the of the organization of American states went to some of these villages that I’m right now talking about and they were threatened as Well, they had to leave the villages under police protection because the soy farmers mobilized the other soy farmers and the international human rights commission of the organization of American was threatened and they put it even in their press official communation that they said we visited those villages indigenous villages because of the threats we want to put on record their press in their press release that we were also intimidated and threatened.
So it is very tense. So but it emphasizes that you need the connection and so it’s only mapping yes all fine and of but you need the connection the line with the authorities that you have that you know that they can protect you. So this the access to justice is as important. So mapping and organizing the access to justice which can be quite you have to sometimes invest in this because people live far from the cities and it’s expensive for them to go to town and so you have to organize this as well otherwise you get more confidence.
No.
Jonah:
Great Amy were you done?
Amy:
Yeah thanks I appreciate that. I’ll listen to everybody else’s questions. Thanks.
Jonah:
Ursula you’re up next. Please introduce yourself as well.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you very much.
Unidentified participant:
I’m sorry. Who’s next?
Unidentified participant:
My name is.
Jonah:
And then Antonio.
Ursula:
Yes, I’m in Bolivia now. I was born and raised here and then I moved to first to Spain and then to United States. I lived in New York for about like 15 years. Now I’m back. And obviously I would like to do something about the Amazon here in Bolivia. So my question is if you are planning to work with other countries, Amazon countries.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes, I am I’ve been in Bolivia as well and I Bolivia of course it gets much less attention than Brazil but for example in the last few years deforestation in Bolivia especially the Amazonian part of Bolivia has been huge and it’s the same problem basically kettle farmers kettle farming and soy farming I did once a consultancy for IUCN World Conservation Union about Jaguar poaching in Bolivia so I know a little bit about the also about the law enforcement system. I think the jaguar is interesting. The jaguar poaching is a good example of the justice system that let’s say the justice system wasn’t so eager to go behind go after wildlife trafficking and poaching of jaguars but after pressure of younger populations of students in Bolivia.
Then the prosecutors they felt kind of pressure to take more action. So I think of my strategy as a criminologist always try to help and stimulate the rule of law and force law enforcement. So this is a little bit more challenging maybe in Bolivia compared to Brazil. It has also to do with resources. Brazil is richer than Bolivia. But I do see a lot of potential because I met NOS’s and I hear that also the indigenous in Bolivia and Bolivia of course is a country where with a majority of indigenous and one of the few countries where the indigenous are quite numerous still so that makes it that there’s I think a lot of potential for force crime prevention and working with communities against poaching and against deforestation.
But with Bolivia I’d like to but then I would study where because with the soy from Brazil it’s more obvious it goes a lot to Europe and to China. So I would have to study a little bit the Bolivian situation with the cattle because I think part of it goes to China. So I would have to let’s say to study the economy a little bit but I do see potential absolutely for Bolivia as well.
Ursula:
Perfect. Now there we have some I would say bigger problem here not just cattle ranching or soybean we also have cocaine production so that’s I would say harder you know from the crime point of view.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
You’re right actually my former specialty used to be illegal drugs and I happen to know quite a lot about the illegal cocaine economy and Bolivia is one three producers and it has increased a lot and I know even for nature protectors there’s some let’s say some part of Bolivia it’s very dangerous to go because the narcos control those territories so indeed about and by the way it’s also in the bord on the Brazilian side the border near Peru and Bolivia and the border in Colombia there and it’s a extra challenge to with the naros and the criminal groups especially now since some organized crime groups are now also in the gold.
Yeah. In illegal gold mining and illegal gold trade partly because it’s gold is also attractive for money laundering and transporting money you know instead of moving the cocaine you can move gold and then so yes I mean huge challenges indeed and with areas that are difficult to go to but on the other hand you can say it even with those challenges it gives it makes it even more important to work with communities, with people and civil society because I think civil society is in kind of unused force and especially if you give international support to local initiatives and you can also give exposure international exposure.
So because it is an international problem all these products are being exported I mean the kettle and soy but also the cocaine. So you can give more exposure to local problems. I think because we have to think as a that’s something I learned from the indigenous. We have to think as a community and I think we now in the 21st century in a world community.
Jonah:
On that note I’m just going to move us to we have three more questions and 13 minutes left. And we will have a call on Koka in the future. Okay. Next up is Antonio. Please introduce yourself and your question and then Julia and then Christina.
Antonio:
Oh thank you very much. Thank you Tim. And thank you Jonah for the opportunity to make you acquaintance. I am Antonio. I’m from Satawi. We basically bridge finance to local organizations in the Amazon mostly cooperatives and local businesses that generate positive impact in the area. So firstly Tim thank you very much. This is comforting being Brazilian to see a foreigner speak with such property, with such knowledge about the Amazon and its problems and its issues. And besides being very fond of Dutch people as a former ABN Emerald Bank employee, one of the most challenging things here in the Amazon is precisely to exercise the police rights for the state in the area.
It’s so vast. Since you know it, you know that this is virtually impossible to do that because of the magnitude of the areas and the territories. But one of the ways people can help is to buy products made in the Amazon, not wood of course, but like Brazilian nuts and other goods that are locally produced by local producers, local and traditional communities in the Amazon because they want to stay there. They want to remain there. They know the value the forest has for them. And so it would be great besides reinforcing the law of course given this these people the means to survive from the forest preventing soy preventing cattle and so on.
This is another a very important export goods we have besides soy and cattle and we could here stay here the whole day talking about it. So I would like much more. It’s not a question but to congratulate you and your initiative and you can count on us. My email is in the chat. Please feel free to contact whatever we can do to help you.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Thank you. Great. Thank you.
Jonah:
Great. Julia, you’re up next. Please introduce yourself as well as your question.
Julia:
Hi. Thanks so much. Really interesting discussion. I’m Julius. I work for the Nature Crime Alliance. It’s an initiative that’s being developed by World Resources Institute together with the Meridian Institute and Folu, the Food and Land Use Alliance. And so we’re really interested in various nature crimes and illegal force deforestation obviously as part of that. I was just interested, you know, out of just in terms of when you were describing the work and then later on in the Q&A, you’ve already been discussing a little bit about the violence in Paris State, but just in terms of any risks and how your research dealt with that and how your pilots have dealt with that in terms of risks to the groups that you’re working with in going around with cameras and you know, tackling the logging company.
So, that was one. And then just as we’re as we’re talking I’m also you know in terms of what’s working and your thoughts on how one can scale something like this and how fast would be really interesting to hear your thoughts.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes. Okay. Well risks I can take talk a lot about risk. Well it’s being a foreigner although I have to say you know my wife is from the Amazon. I have an educated wife from the Amazon and my children are born in the Amazon that gives me so I have a working permit so I can always be legally in Brazil. So that helps and then I’ve given a lot of trainings and workshops to public prosecutors. I didn’t mention it yet, but I give train and I give classes to prosecutors in the Netherlands, but also to prosecutors and judges in Brazil and I’m usually the only foreigner giving these courses.
I’m also the lead consultant for UNODC on force crime. You and so I have this academic specialty. So this helps me. So I that’s what the prosecutor I teach to prosecutor because in Brazil there’s a lot of crime but not much criminology. That’s the problem. So they like my classes and so but obviously this also helps me personally. I’m very happy that I know dozens of public prosecutors because everybody in Brazil knows public prosecutors are difficult to corrupt, you know. So that gives me some extra protection too and they take well care of me.
So it’s the risk, you know. So but then the risk is huge and for example the indigenous who patrol they are at least 12 you know so or 15 or 20 to outnumber the logging gang and it is very dangerous chief dada my main partner he when he registered his indigenous territory we’re talking about more than 10 years ago he the death threats arrived I mean they’ve they’ve poisoned his dogs they’ve burned his house but he was kidnapped and tortured watch it. But he also managed to get protection. So for over 10 years now, he is in the official human rights program.
So he has a personal police escort. So when I meet him every time, we have police escort. So many places I go to, we go with police escort. So even though there’s challenges of the law enforcement system, we also get help of the law enforcement system. So but it of course but we have to be careful and sometimes I stay low profile. I have luckily many friends and who take care of me and of course the indigenous take well care of me but yes me I’m quite tall. I don’t look like an they don’t look indigenous.
So I stay low profile with my friends but oftentimes also with police protection. Actually this month there will be a big article in detite the German newspaper for those who read but when we there will be describe it because we were there with police or squ. So yes there are serious challenges but it is also possible to do things a bit well with less risk but scaling we my idea was always to develop something that was cheap that they that they can do themselves and that’s efficient and something that you can scale and expand and so that was always my intention.
I think it’s very in science-based and especially crime science-based because we need more science-based interventions. I think a lot of NOS’s are trying things, but we should, you know, we should test them and make sure they’re based on theories and best practices. So, yes, ours can be scaled up to other indigenous territories for sure. That’s the lowhanging fruit. And we discussed this with the umbrella organizations already, the FIPA, the Federation of Indigenous People of Parate. Discuss it with the board members of the Quap the Federation of Indigenous People of the whole Brazilian Amazon.
There are actually we are still small but there’s a lot of indigenous leaders and communities knocking on my door on my WhatsApp door asking for help. So we can easily actually with the indigenous and chieft we are ready to roll it out to others and there’s other communities that want us our want us to go there. If we have more funding I mean we have limited fund we still limited funding but because it’s quite expensive just only the transport costs yeah to patrol the territory is expensive just the gasoline for boats motorcycles cars and people don’t have the money economy so these are huge expenditures for the indigenous even for me I because the more the deeper you go into the Amazon the higher the gasoline prices it’s extremely expensive.
So just the patrolling go to the other side sometimes of the indigenous territory is for them a major cost and so this is very often underestimated the size like Antonia it’s so huge and just and then sometimes indigenous say oh but just to go to the other side we need 60 liters of gas gasoline just to go there and then you’re not yet talking about camping and patrolling and then going back to the city to report the crimes or because they usually don’t have phones or technologies you know it’s only starting now that indigenous communities start to have internet and what so the huge challenge is just protecting it on the ground and it’s quite expensive but it’s doable.
Absolutely.
Jonah:
Okay. Last question and then we’ll open up to a couple others to offer context. Christina, please introduce yourself and your question.
Christina:
Yeah. Hi Tim, thanks so much. So I’m Christina Belli. I’m from Venezuela. I’m sitting in Washington DC but my work is all in Venezuela. I started an advocacy group called SOS Orinino, which is basically reporting and monitoring on all the illegal mining that’s occurring in Venezuela. And it if you think Brazil is bad, this is the far west. Okay, I have a really big challenge for you and that is what do we do about the Gimin Bados coming over the Brazilian border into southern Venezuela? So, this is Yanomami land. I’m interested to know whether you’re working with a Yanomami.
Have they reached out to you on your WhatsApp? So we gave we this amazing Yanomami contacted us and said that he would be willing to go to his hometown, home village, community in the upper full of Gimos, at least 80 mining sites and he would take photos if we gave him a phone. So, we’ve given him and one of his buddies a phone and we have these incredible photos. The problem is that if we publish them, the community will immediately know that it was him and that would put him at risk.
So, he’s like, “Use the photos to prove to whoever needs to know.” And of course here we’re working against the Venezuelan regime because Maruro is the one who is totally not only allowing this but is completely in partnership with the Gimpos and the Colombian guerilla to do this illegal mining. So we have to go international. We cannot there is no Venezuelan entity that will be interested in doing in law enforcement or anything on the contrary and we all we have to work anonymously and everybody’s undercover and you know it’s a really tough situation.
So you know I’m just interested from a from you know from your experience you know how can we work around this situation which is so desperate. We’ve already reached out to a couple of journalists and we’re thinking of doing some big stories, but the problem is that we cannot publish the photos.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes, I see. I understand what you’re saying. It’s worse. And I Well, actually, one of my former students, Brah Abus, do you know him? He’s an investigative journalist. He’s one of my former students. He’s a criminology student. So I would send because he is like me he’s an adventurer younger and very comfortable in Venezuela. So I would send Bam who is who has published in international. So I would ask his advice but that was the first thing but then the Yanomami of course is a huge issue you know in the Brazilian side just for the people who are just about the scale.
So Yanami there were approximately 40,000 illegal gold miners. That’s the size. Now two three weeks ago there was this big law enforcement operation on the Brazilian site. I don’t know if you follow that. It was really interesting because and the Brazilian federal police was a big operation and they went after the planes. They seized more than 100 planes. So just the skill of illegal mining because the planes supplied everything, the food, the gasoline, everything. So it was very smart to focus on the planes because theirs are the they are the crime facilitators in my language.
So you have to focus on the crime facilitators. The planes are so they took them out. So that was very smart.
Christina:
Serious challenge is that PCC the biggest criminal organization of Brazil is involved is active there as well. So it’s all related with the cocaine and the money. So these huge challenges, but what would I do?
Christina:
And excuse me, Tim and the problem is that you know the Brazilian law enforcement is doing that on the Brazilian side, but instead of taking they blow up the planes and the helicopters, but they don’t get rid of the Gimpedo. So the Galipedos go up north over the border into Venezuela where they have safe haven from the Venezuelan regime.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
I see. Well, the same problem is in Surinam. There’s also many Brazilian gin peros illegal gold miners in Surinam. So because they used to be in Brazil and now they it went to other countries namely you know Venezuela, Surinam, Guyana as well. I think for the time being international exposure and maybe put because they’re from Brazil maybe put some international exposure maybe to put some a little bit pressure on Brazil as well because Brazil takes a bit more action on their side of the border or get them back. But yes, I mean, well, I don’t know.
I don’t have short-term solutions for Venezuela. It’s also because there’s also the corruption and the cocaine money which complicates it even further. You probably know about this. There’s some quite some cocaine flows going there as well with money and weapons which is makes it very complicated. But the guy taking the pictures, the only thing is that you have to make them if people are alone or small groups, they’re always vulnerable. So you have to make the groups bigger and try to make alliances and indigenous alliances and then support them. Another thing that I would do is the New York Times photographer of Brazil, Victor, forgot his last name.
I he specialized in the Yanomami. So I would discuss it with him as well. What he can do or his ideas and people who know the area. So, it’s always important to first hear their opinions and then see what is possible. But there are no easy solutions of course to you understand. But international exposure I think that’s the main thing because we hear much more Brazilian in Venezuela we hear almost nothing. So it could help to maybe fund some journalists in to publish in different languages for example to make it that’s what I also believe these all these problems are hidden in the Amazon the deep in the Amazon let’s try we are a world community now let’s try to get it into the news that we can at least more people know about it and then we can start thinking about possible solutions.
Jonah:
Okay on that note I want to recognize that we are at the top of the hour just past the top of the hour for those of you who need to go. You know, class dismissed. This is the moment in time where we usually switch over to what I call water cooler time. Which is where I leave the chat room open. It’s unstructured conversation. There are a couple of people who, had several things to share, a lot of links that they shared that I’d like to call on just to share in this moment.
Tim, are you able to stick around for a little while?
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes, absolutely.
Jonah:
Okay, great. So Chip and Tom please feel free to share what’s going on and otherwise the room is open everybody please share your contact information with each other. Lots of people hungry to learn and follow up. Chip why don’t you start?
Chip:
Sure. Hi everybody and thanks so much for this session. Thanks so much Tim, Tom and of course Jonah. These are always very interesting and great to meet people. I just dropped a couple links that of work that we do. There’s a couple other colleagues I may have dropped off. There was Julia and Ruth was noon is still there. Something that we’re working on about the nature crime alliance. It’s a new initiative that we’re trying to pull together with the Murdian Institute and some others as Julia said and you can find information in that link there and I think I dropped in the also the paper that we did for the climate and land use alliance which is an alliance of foundations a lot of them work in the Amazon you know Ford was mentioned talking about this issue and why it’s not just an environmental issue and why it’s important and related to human rights and other things across various kinds of crime that we sort of lump together as nature crime illegal mining land clearing and all those kinds of things.
So, anyone who’s interested, I’m easy to find on the internet. See Barbara atwi.org. Just let me know at the World Resources Institute and myself and my colleagues always interested to talk about these issues. So, thanks.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yeah, maybe we can just very quickly react because I later this month will be a higher education module by the UN will be online and I was the lead author. I will put the link where it will be published and it will give module for education for justice of the UN ODC and it’s called illegal exploitation of wild flora and it’s with peer-reviewed with peer review of 10 people I think a very good overview I’m the lead author so I’m a little bit biased maybe but and with also about plants because that’s very some plant biologist say this plant blindness there’s so much emphasis on trees whereas there’s a lot of illegal trading plants as well.
But I’ll put the link on the in the in the chat.
Jonah:
Great. Tom, did you want to share some from your comments?
Tom:
Yeah, sure. Well, I think I’ve shared a few things which I hope people have been able to read as the conversation’s been ongoing. Just to give our guests a little bit more context. You’ve obviously heard of the tremendous success Tim’s had which has been mainly through Chief Dada who is within Paris within the Tapios and he’s one of the leading spokesman of the region. Now he’s part of the Barari people who are one of 13 ethnic groups within the Tapios region or the lower Tapios to be more precise. And what we’re doing Tim and myself via forest forces in Cinchi is now scaling up the success he’s had with the Barari people with Chief Dada and scaling this up now to a much larger scale across these 13 ethnic groups which is around 80 different communities in this in this area.
So this is kind of what I suppose you would consider is phase two. Phase one has been a success. This is phase two. And if this is successful and we’re in the process of trying to raise the funding at the moment, then of course things like the interest which we’re seeing on the call is amazing because I think the possibilities to scale this and incorporate u these strategies in other places. I’ve seen comments from Ecuador and Venezuela and other parts of the Amazon and Bolivia I think are fantastic. Couple of other things I just wanted to mention.
One and I’ve seen some of the other comments. I really do think this multifaceted approach is needed. My opinion and I think Tim’s opinion is access to justice has to be the first point though because without that even good intentions can cause more damage. And that’s why it’s important to have these close working relationships with the communities. But there is of course fantastic opportunities for sustainable investment as well. I’m sure Tim can tell you a bit more about that as well within the Tapios. Things like rubber and other things which the region is famous for.
And finally just a couple of the things I wanted to mention because it might be interesting to the group. We are not just taking this as a sort of underground project. There will be a big campaign which is running with this. We’re working with one of the world’s biggest advertising agencies who some of you may know in Widen and Kennedy who are offices all over the world. So that’s something which is going on behind the scenes at the moment. And in addition to this and something I mentioned to Jonah and could be interesting to some others is we’re looking at creating a lawyers for the Amazon group because in another in a another sort of part of my life I run a large international legal network.
And I think there’s a fantastic potential to bring both environmental defense lawyers together, but also commercial lawyers, who actually have an interest and passion. And we’re hoping to build this in the near future. So, that’s it from me for now.
Jonah:
Great. Others welcome to comment, ask questions. The floor is open.
Ruth:
Hi, sorry this is Ruth Nagaron. Just very quickly, I wonder if you can talk a little bit team and Tom about you know the financial sustainability of the monitoring and you know there are other groups in Peru that are doing monitoring with communities or working with empowering communities to monitor their lands but also facing you know in addition to the risks to the communities facing you know financial challenges. I mean are there you know models to help finance these activities? M.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Well financial challenges there are many of course for especially indigenous communities especially those that suffer from deforestation because they used to hunt and fish and collect food and now because of deforestation especially in the lower tapoor many indigenous communities are surrounded by soy fields and the soybean farming is much more problematic to them than the kettle farming because the soybean farmers They spray pesticides and herbicides like glyphosits. So this also kills all the small garden food gardens of the indigenous and with the spraying all these insects from the soy fields go to the to the little gardens of the indigenous.
So it’s really for their own food so that they produce less food. So this is a huge problem. But the monitoring so basically we I just support them. I give them equipment and sometimes money for gasoline and all types of equipment to build camps in a forest or to really patrol the territory against illegal invasions. So I really only help them with equipment to help them well yeah with equipment to monitor and to get and access to justice. That’s what how we help them. I’m not sure if I understand your question about financial sustainability but well.
Unidentified participant:
Yes.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
But I have to say but the investments are quite small. I mean if you I mean we it’s really quite cheap. I mean for let’s say a thousand US dollars you can already help one community with equipment so that they can start monitoring sometimes to go to the city to report the crimes can be and need a prosecutor. So that can be you know you need a little bit depending on where they live it cost some extra money but still it doesn’t have to cost a lot of money to support the community but then it depends also of course the size of the community like if you want to patrol Yanomami which is the size of Netherlands or Switzerland and then of course it was primary rainforce of course it’s intensive labor intensive and so and it and it’s huge so it cost more money just by the transport cost but I think you don’t need many costs it’s really mostly transport.
Ruth:
Thank you. Yeah, sorry. So if I can expand a little bit. Yeah, I meant yes you know sometimes these monitoring activities become a job, right? So and that is the case you know financial sustainability to support the community people that their job is to monitor. That’s what I meant.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Okay. No, until now we haven’t done that because it’s really their intrinsic interest. So we only pay for the cost but we’ve never paid salaries or something for anyone to anyone.
Ruth:
Thank you.
Jonah:
It looks like Chip and then Christian.
Chip:
Just a quick thing I wanted to mention on that topic that Ruth raised on financing. I think that is a I mean I’ve seen this I used to do this in Indonesia a lot with you know force monitors and things and you get bright young dedicated people who will do this and then they get older they get married they get families they have things like that and they can’t keep on doing it just as a thing on the side and so there is you know if you want to institutionalize and particularly we do this a lot with independent monitors in the Congo basin to professionalize what they’re doing so that the information that they’re producing then can be used say in legal cases and other things like that.
It does take some money, but what I really wanted to say is that you had this commitment at the Glasgow climate change meeting. I don’t know if any of you were there. I was there and there was a big indigenous presence there including from the Amazon basin and there were commitments of there’s a $ 1.7 billion fund that has been committed to for to try and get resources directly into the hands of in of indigenous communities on the ground, not just the usual big donor stuff. A lot of money was committed and honestly a lot of these donors don’t really have the slightest idea how to effectively spend that and meet their commitments.
So I think to the extent that we can help them to figure out the right way to do it. So it’s maybe it’s not a lot of money but it’s you know secure money going to the right people for the right things you know and things like that is there’s an opportunity here I think that per perhaps wasn’t there a few years ago. There are some major commitments and you can read about all this stuff online if you go and you know just look up indigenous fund commitments you know COP 26 there was it was it was quite interesting and exciting to see that there was a real recognition and that not only that there needs to be more money but that who should control how that money is spent there is some changes at least on the part of some donors about that kind of thinking.
Christian:
Question so first of all Tim thank you so much for the great beautiful work you’ve been doing. And I have a question here. As we all know the people that have witnessed the deforestation Amazon they are also the most vulnerable ones because you know if they take pictures and all that like been discussed here you know very easy to identify them and you know that region can be very violent as we know. So my question is do you know of any initiatives that use satellite imagery in a way that maybe the people on the ground will be able to inform you know the image collectors that there’s some degradation in some area.
So and then you know there will be satellite imagery and will register that there’s a level of deforestation in a certain area in a way that’s legally valid. So you have proof of a fact, proof of a violation in a way that you know then the district attorneys and whatever authorities will have to act on it without exposing the people on the ground. I asked that because I remember some years ago there was a partnership with I think it was Google and one of the one of the Amazonian ethnicities that were creating a conservation project and Google was doing the satellite imagery for reforestation protection.
So do you because I know some areas of the Amazon they have very good satellite coverage some not as much but can we do something like that because then the stewards the people that will bring up the violations will not be exposed. Do you know of any initiatives in that direction?
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes it is possible but actually with our model they don’t have to be exposed because we again we have the access to justice strategy. So a chief who is the official authority of an of an area can bring or somebody on his or her behalf can bring the picture to the enforcement authorities. They can if they have the court GPS coordinates they can have their own satellite picture immediately and the per the person who reports the crime doesn’t have to be exposed. It’s just that the evidence is there on behalf of the community.
So the person doesn’t have to be exposed. But another answer to your question, yes, of course, it’s very useful to use the satellite data and Brazil that’s why I also came up with this idea because Brazil has an advanced satellite system and law enforcement has these rooms with screens. So that’s why that’s why I came up with the idea because Brazil has the system. So you want to use the system but with about the satellites I want to make one remark of obviously it’s very and I use global forest watch as well and all the and other satellite system and of world resources institute where I’ve been once but they have a delay that’s underestimated because and we talk about rainforest tropical rainforest which half of the year they have cloud cover and still most satellites are optical there are radar satellites but they only have a limited scope.
So most are still optical and the loggers and they know they have adapted to that. So they log when it’s during the rainy season when there’s cloud cover and but I’ve with the federal police I’ve been in many meetings with Brazilian law enforcement when and generally with the satellite pictures that they take it takes up to a week before a law enforcement gets them on his or her screen because they have to be filtered and actually they have to be sent and so it takes time. So there’s this delay and the advantage of working with the communities they are on the ground and so the satellites has always this delay whereas people on the ground they hear and see things they hear motorcycles they hear trucks or they see them they see huge barges with for the logs so there that’s the local intelligence that’s faster so that’s why I believe we have to use the local intelligence and I would invest in let’s say radio and telephone systems that if they say hey there’s some guy there’s 20 trucks arriving here, what would they want to do?
They are going to take trees out. So, and then you’re faster. So, I’m I think so the satellite, yes, but they’re late. There’s the delay. Whereas the local intelligence, you have to use the local intelligence, the people under the canopy and under the cloud cover. And then if you can connect them to the law enforcement system, then you can be more efficient. And they know for if the law enforcement arrive, the people who know, they know. For example, we I didn’t tell everything, but some of the GPS cameras, they take pictures.
For example, sometimes the loggers are making new logging roads. So the locals can take pictures. Click, click, click, click. Here are the new logging roads. Here they’re preparing because this large scale deforestation, some people, not you, but sometimes I give presentations, people say, “Oh, but these poor people have to eat.” We’re not talking about poor people. We’re talking about this the timber. They fly in with their private jets. And it’s huge equipments, you know, and so it’s a lot of money. These are big operations. But the locals, they know this.
They hear this. So, we have to use much more this local this local intelligence, but that’s dangerous. So, that’s why we have to connect them one to the law enforcement system. And ideally, that’s what Tom and I want are planning now to have more equipment and radio and internet. And I’m talking to Microsoft. Maybe they want to help. I want to have a better communication system that we can report the crimes faster, you know, to speed this all up. But yes, of course, we have to use satellite images as well.
Christian:
Okay. Thank you. Very good.
Unidentified participant:
Very good.
Jonah:
Antonio and Ruth, you have your hands raised. Go ahead.
Antonio:
Just a quick remark on what Tim was mentioning about the logistics. Yes, we have to counteract people on the ground because logistics in Yemen is so complicated that u the armed forces in Brazil do quite a good job. Tim probably knows that. But the point is you can’t send a plane to check on a deforestation area because depending on where it is, there’s no infrastructure for you to refuel and come back. So this is problematic. If you count with people on the ground and you give them the resources they need, they will do the job.
They will do the job for you in as they are fishing for themselves, as they are collecting for themselves, they do the job. And then you can go exactly where you need to. And yes, as I pointed out in the chat here, this is it, Tim. This is a big money in this logging business. And they are like fortune soldiers. There’s no headquarters to report. There’s not a there’s not a company where you go to its headquarters and okay, you arrest the CEO and the operation is done. This is not how it happens.
There’s a very emblematic case here in the Amazon. Sister Dhy Stang, she was murdered because she started to talk. She began to be vocal about the violations against the peoples of the forest. So this is this is a very complicated place.
Jonah:
Ruth.
Ruth:
Just to update since Tim was talking a little bit about the limitations of satellite monitoring global forest watch is coming up with u generation of deforestation alerts based on radar. So hopefully that will also help you know limit the time limitations.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
I’d like to react. Yeah. No, radar satellites I think you know that can kind of look through the clouds. I think they should be they’re very useful. They’re only used limitedly now. And I think they could be used because you can kind of predict where the deforestation will be. I mean it is you know we can we know the trends. We know where the loggers are, where the miners are. So it would be I think effective to use radar satellites more locally, more specifically certain force crime hotspots that you can know, oh right, they’re making a new logging road there and then law enforcement.
The problem now with there has been huge budget cuts with forest law enforcement. So for law enforcement is doesn’t have its full capacity so to say at this moment. But at one point this will happen. There will be more law enforcement. There’s no other way that the you know so either this government or the next government there will be more force law enforcement and we have to look at how can we connect communities forest communities to the forest law enforcement system. I think that’s really a very practical step ahead.
Jonah:
I have one question and then Chip will go and that’s about the financing. So I hear the story of private planes and big machinery coming in, but I have also been told that those who are employed by illegal loggers tend to be people from destitute communities, ve very poor people. That’s not necessarily the bounty hunters. So I’m wondering what strategy local income mechanisms you know whether it’s force friendly economy or payment free ecosystem services might be able to reduce the mobility of the illegal loggers. Are the illegal loggers really always 100% of the time bounty hunters coming from, you know, outside the region or does the creation of local income alternatives you know, make it more costly or reduce the you know, the readiness of illegal loggers to come in?
And what would what do the incomes look like of the illegal loggers? You know, those who are just sort of hired to be front of the line and those who are the big money behind it.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
First of all, so also the logging about 80% most of the logging, most of the mining is illegal and there’s a lot of modern slave labor, right? It’s some prosecutors say there’s almost no logging without forced labor and so it’s exploitation. So there’s a lot of they break another other laws. I mean, it’s just child abuse and slave labor. There’s a lot of crimes connect also to the with the cattle farming. So I but right now a lot of people think that as if there’s only cattle and only soy and only gold and only wood that can be extracted but like Tom Wheeler saying there’s a lot of other possibilities for supporting the local economy and I’ve I’m thinking about this for years.
For example, Asai is one of them. It’s the it’s the most widespread palm tree in the Amazon. It’s a very useful plant and they are see everywhere. It’s some in some health food store in the US you can buy it but it could be for example this is one of the things people have calculated this if you instead of cattle you would invest more in asai in asai you cannot grow it and harvest it without the locals. I mean because you have to climb those palm trees and that could be something people have made calculations about the possibility of as rubber.
Well Jonah and I we briefly discussed rubber the other day when we met here online the tapjo is where we work lower tapoor in the lower Amazon is where the a lot of the rubber came from. Actually I don’t know this is a story in the 19th century when the 70,000 rubber seeds were stolen from the Amazon transferred to the UK which led to rubber plantations in Asia. For those who don’t know, all the rubber in Asia is from seeds from the Amazon that was smuggled from Santang in the exactly where the tapoor is in the Amazon River meet.
So, and Henry Wickham, the British person in the late 19th century who organized this, who took all the seats, he chose this area because of the rich rubber culture. And interestingly, if you I go to you see a there’s still a lot of rubber trees. You can see all the markings of so they’re still all there and I think rubber. I asked I remember the last time I rented the bicycle in the Amazon in the village where I was staying. I rented the bicycle and I asked the bicycle man and said, “Hey, where does the do your tires come from?
They all come from Asia.” And said, “Gee, we have all” and I said, “Isn’t it strange? You know that rubber is from here with all these rubber trees here in the forest, but the rubber on the bicycles in Brazil, they’re all from Asia. Wouldn’t it be nice to have a Amazonian rubber? I think a lot of people here in Amsterdam with all the bicycles would love it the ecological to have bike or car tires Amazonian rubber because now in Laos in Southeast Asia there’s big plantations. There’s deforestation for rubber whereas rubbish from the Amazon and interestingly in the Amazon you cannot have big rubber plantations.
It’s also Henry Ford when he built Fort Langia in the 1930s and 20 it was a big economic disaster because he thought he could build rur plantations. No, interestingly rubber from the Amazon is by nature sustainable because the rubber trees are dispersed in the forest. You cannot have because of insects and fungus big plantations. So rubber tappers want to preserve the forest and the rubber in the Amazon only grows in the forest. So it would be fantastic to stimulate rubber culture cultivation from the Amazon again as it was in the 19th century.
Bring it back to the Amazon where it came from. And then also by the way my wife is a she’s a tourist molga. She started tourism in the Amazon and there also for tourism I always struck that people if want to see a rainforest they go to Costa Rica whereas and in the Amazon if you travel you always see no tourist this and it has so much potential different types of tourism community tourism nature tourism ecological tourism adventure tourism all kinds of I think I there’s a lot of potential also with community tourism with community so I and well there’s still other products you can think of but I think there’s more than just wood, you know, there’s more u more the economy has much more to offer, I think, with communities than in other products than only wood.
Jonah:
Go ahead, Chip.
Chip:
Thanks. I just wanted to make one two quick points of information. I don’t know if you know the group Health and Harmony, but in talking about you know incentives at the local level. It’s an interesting group that I’ve heard a lot about their work and I know them. They started in Indonesia and they worked out in Brazil and Madagascar. It’s basically combining local rural health care as an incentive to get people out of illegal logging that you know basically it was if you guys stop the illegal logging we’ll you know we’ll give you free health care in our clinic.
And sort of combining focusing on rural health with dealing with that has been you know it’s not you know it’s not going to work everywhere but it’s worked in some places and that sort of gets to my second point is you got to really understand what the illicit economy that you’re approaching how it works in Madagascar. I remember being in the northeast 2015 and asking some it was some cops in a village and some other people. I said, “So, who does the illegal rosewood logging here?” And they just laughed and they said, “Well, when the buyers are in town, everybody drops whatever they’re doing and they go on these gangs and you know, no one’s selling trees.
They’re all just being hired by a foreman to go out and it’s pretty nasty work, but it’s you know, it’s cash income and they have very little cash income there. They have, you know, animals in a fairly decent subsistance economy.” But he said when the buyers aren’t around the you know the big Chinese companies, nobody cuts rosewood. It’s hard to cut. It’s heavy. It’s like you know it’s only it’s only a cash economy thing. So you know like understanding how to break that link there is probably very different from looking at the gamas or things in other places.
So, I guess it’s just a plea for having a, you know, a good locally based analysis of who’s actually doing what and what are the economic incentives because a that’s the only way that you can cut it off on the elicit economy and b the only way you can figure out what might be incentives that would be good for the local community that they’re going to accept and is, you know, is going to fit with what their needs are and their, you know, approach to life.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yes. Well, just a very short quick reaction. I think I know about the rosewood roots. It’s also for my UN work in Madagascar, which of course is a huge issue. But in the Amazon, it’s not the case. I would say that everybody’s involved. It’s really the locals are usually not involved in this illegal locking. It’s certainly not the indigenous. It’s extremely rare. And so it’s really people from the outside and the logging companies are usually white Brazilians from really the south of Brazil, from Sa Paulo. And there’s also quite some racism there I must say that they think ah these foresters are standing here these indigenous doing nothing just in the forest we are exploiting it we are bringing a cash economy here and so and they know it’s illegal and it’s really they’re corporate criminals in my you know they know they go there because there’s crime opportunities and it’s kind of a culture it’s a criminal subculture between certain you Because most of the loggers are doing it illegally.
Again, 90% is illegal. And maybe some of you heard last year there was this big timber seizure of 130,000 cubic meters. Difficult to imagine that you need about 7,000 big trucks to transport it. And this was exported to the US into Europe. And then in the US there was law enforcement with the lacy act and eventually this led to US Brazilian contact and the Brazilian minister of the environment had to resign Salis. This was last June because of this illegal logging operation. So they were so it’s huge but it just shows 7,000 trucks to transport it one.
It’s we’re talking about huge operations and with big equipment and sometimes when I go to the front line to near indigenous territories you see these huge barges see truck after truck after truck it’s largecale illegal exploitation. So it’s I mean the only thing okay we can of course we should help some community but it’s really we’re talking about big criminal organizations that we should just stop them because the locals mostly suffer from it and there’s just a few people who profit from it.
Jonah:
Great. Any other questions before we go? Thank you everybody for such an amazing call. There will be lots to follow up. Tim, you’re a popular guy.
Unidentified participant:
Well,.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Well, yes. Well, I’m happy and honored that I could share our experiences and I cannot emphasize enough that we if we want to protect the Amazon, we have to work with the traditional forest communities. And there’s many more opportunities than people think and it’s much easier to do. We just have to try it and well we have to win the trust but it’s possible and the indigenous organizations are ready and so are we. So we are if you want to support or join whatever we can talk again please contact me.
My email is I put it in timforestforce.org or Tom Wheeler. Tom did you put your email as well? So you can contact us both and if you want to know more or work with us or support us.
Unidentified participant:
We need we need to change our mindset too.
Tim Boekhout van Solinge:
Yeah having like a top down approach but it takes time to really understand this culture and unlearn what we’ve learned.
Jonah:
Awesome. A life journey. Culture change and economics are two other parts of this equation that I hope we go to deeper on a deeper on a future call but I’m going to end the call for now.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Thanks so much everybody.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you everybody.
Unidentified participant:
Yes. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
We’ll see you soon.
Unidentified participant:
Bye everyone.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. Bye. Bye. I’m going to stop the recording. Hold on one second.